Andrew Coyne And The Cult Of Right Wing ‘Truthiness’

Reading Andrew Coyne’s column in Thursday’s Leader-Post says a lot more about Andrew Coyne than the subject he talks about. It’s also a perfect example of how ‘magical thinking’ and ‘truthiness’ has corrupted political thought.

A bit of background. In the Ontario provincial election, Conservative Party leader Tim Hudak says his party’s platform will create a million jobs in his first term. The problem is, as Jim Stanford has pointed out, Hudak’s proposal has one big flaw: his math is off. By confusing years of employment with permanent jobs, Hudak’s math is off by a factor of eight.

When confronted with this fact, not just by Stanford but by many major economists, Hudak says they’re wrong and he’s right, though he won’t say where those economists are wrong and his data is right. And when confronted with this, Andrew Coyne says, in effect, so what if Hudak is wrong? He sounds right, and that’s good enough not only for me but also for the province of Ontario.

Usually a candidate who can’t ensure that his staff are capable of doing basic math is a laughingstock, consigned to the dustbin of history. That may yet still happen with Tim Hudak, since the election campaign has about a week or two to run.

But Hudak seems to have a lot of political enablers, just as Rob Ford did. Enablers such as Coyne. The whole concept of ‘truthiness’, as Stephen Colbert explained, is the idea of wanting something to be true, whether or not it is true. Even though, for example, the New York Rangers defeated the Montreal Canadiens in the Stanley Cup semi-finals, there’s probably a few Habs fans dreaming of what Rue Ste. Catherines would be like with a Stanley Cup parade next month. Hudak is the political equivalent of someone pandering to that fantasy, and Coyne is one of those doing the fantasizing.

Someone who isn’t competent enough to understand basic mathematical mistakes shound’t be premier of a province, that goes without saying. A newspaper columnist who endorses a political leader who makes those mistakes because the candidate is saying things the columnist wants to hear is not a credible columnist.

Author: Stephen LaRose

2006 winner of the Canadian Association of University Teachers's Award of Excellence in Journalism for a bunch of prairie dog stuff. Invited into the best homes in Regina. Once.

7 thoughts on “Andrew Coyne And The Cult Of Right Wing ‘Truthiness’”

  1. Great post articulating what I believe is Mr Coyne’s weakness. Last paragraph is a gem– wish I’d said that!

  2. Someone who isn’t competent enough to spell basic contractions shouldn’t be a writer, that goes without saying.

    Just jokes, Rosie! Good post.

  3. I feel like we give Mr. LaRose a lot of flack on here, but he does raise a good point about the media and the political process.

    Rob Ford claims to have saved Toronto “one billion dollars.” Does it matter if that figure has to be adjusted to include foreign direct investment and other numbers of the like? The answer, as is the truth, is relative.

    Republicans and Canadian Tories knows this very well: it does not matter what the numbers are: if you keep repeating something often enough, it will be accepted by your voter bloc (in the case of Republicans and Tories, this bloc is usually a group of people who are not of the ilk to second guess an authority figure).

  4. The whole concept of “creating 1 million new jobs” is flawed and based only in “truthiness”. Or, “he” may “create” 1 million new jobs, but most of them will suck – $10.50/hour, no benefits for 12 months. You can only convert so many empty factories into federally-licenced marijuana grow-ops.

  5. As for Horwath, I don’t really like how she’s run the campaign and frankly, I wouidn’t have voted that Liberal budget down. I’m pretty sure this Hudek troll will sneak thru with a minority, based mostly on a premature sense of Liberal-fatigue (how pretty much all Conservative parties get elected federally) and a general sense of ‘Meh’ towards the NDP campaign. Altho she’s not doing as poorly as that Dix wimp from BC.

  6. The Cos had the nerve to place an Action Plan sign on my street ( about 5 yrs ago), ooh the CoR paved the road ; any new hires ..maybe. Any new jobs for local business? Nope.

Comments are closed.